October 21, 2017

The Oversight of Elders

By Harry Pickup, Jr.

The oversight of churches of Christ has been assigned to godly and mature Christians who are called in
the New Testament bv the names bishop, elder or presbyter, SUCH MEN ARE NOT OFFICERS IN THE
REAL MEANING OF THE WORD. THEY ARE SIMPLY MATURE CHRISTIANS WHO BY VIRTUE
OF OUTSTANDINGLY SUCCESSFUL CHRISTIAN LIVES ARE ABLE TO EXERCISE INFLUENCE
AND LEADERSHIP OVER CHRISTIANS. These men are those who recognize the need for and
qualifications of bishops and who prepare themselves accordingly. The New Testament lays down specific
qualifications to fulfill the work which these men are assigned by God to do. Christians recognize those who
meet the divine standard and ask such men to "watch for their souls."


ELDERS ARE GODLY MEN WHOSE INFLUENCE IS GREAT BECAUSE OF THEIR SPIRITUAL
MATURITY. THEY COMMAND OUR RESPECT BECAUSE OF WHAT THEY DO. THEY ARE NOT
ENTITLED TO SUBMISSION BECAUSE OF AN OFFICE WHICH THEY HOLD BUT RATHER
BECAUSE OF DUTIES WHICH THEY PERFORM BECAUSE OF QUALIFICATIONS THEY POSSESS.
The Holy Spirit has enjoined upon us the necessitv "to esteem them exceeding highly in love for their work's
sake." I Thess. 5:13. We are to acknowledge those who labor among us who are over us in the Lord and who
admonish us in our duties as Christians. I Thess. 5:12.


EVEN THOUGH THESE MEN HAVE UNUSUALLY HIGH QUALIFICATIONS, THEY ARE NOT
QUALIFIED TO RULE IN MATTERS OF FAITH. When they attempt to do it, they attempt to do what even
apostles could not do. The apostle Paul informed the Corinthians, "Not that we have lordship over your faith,
but are helpers of your joy." 2 Cor. 1:24. No one but God determines what one must believe. No one but
inspired men reveal what God ordained men are to believe. And no one but qualified men have the right to
proclaim "the faith" by which we are saved. THE RESPONSIBILITY OF ELDERS NEEDS TO BE
RESTUDIED BECAUSE OF APPARENT IGNORANCE ON THE SUBJECT.


(1) THE FACT OF IT. The Holy Spirit made men overseers of a church of Christ. Elders are made
overseers just as men are made Christians - by obeying the word of truth. The Holy Spirit has outlined their
work and revealed their qualifications. When they meet the qualifications, Christians then have the right to ask
them to assume the responsibility. Bishops oversee the working together of Christians for the furtherance of
the gospel. Phil. 1:1-5. Whatever it is that Christians do together in fellowship as a local church, elders oversee.


(2) THE WHAT OF IT. Elders watch in behalf of the souls of Christians. In the day of judgment, God
shall hold them accountable for this responsibility. The fact that they will have to give an account for what they
have done in this regard sobers them and points out the seriousness of their duty. Christians are admonished
to obey them that have the rule over us and submit to them. Heb. 13:17. Since elders do not rule in matters of
faith, they are limited to oversee in matters of expediency. They apply the gospel of Jesus Christ to the given
needs of Christians.


ELDERS TEND THE FLOCK OF GOD. I Pet. 5:2. Thev exercise their oversight "not of constraint but
willingly according to the will of God ; nor yet for filthy lucre but of a ready mind." They do not exercise
lordship and authority as men in government do. Matt. 20:25. They rule over the church as a father rules over
his house and lead Christians as the school master leads the pupil.


The flock which they oversee is, of course, a local church. The local church is the cooperation of Christians
in the God-ordained purposes of work and worship. What Christians do in this fellowship, elders oversee. When
Christians sent money to be distributed among the needy of a church, it was sent to elders. Acts 11:30. Since
elders oversee whatever a local church does and since the church was called upon to make decisions in such
things as discipline (I Cor. 5:3f) and selection of messengers (I Cor. 16:3) and the sending of funds to the
support of gospel preachers (Phil. 5:15), it necessarily follows that elders must have overseen this. The New
Testament authorizes elders to oversee the work of a local church. It would be unscriptural for elders to
delegate oversight of such work either to a purely human institution or to another church of Christ.


It has been shown in the study of this point that elders watch for souls and therefore are primarily
concerned about spiritual affairs. Elders do not oversee Christians in their secular affairs except and insofar
as those affairs affect the Christians' relationship to God. For example, it is true that elders do not rule over
homes and schools. But some material matters do come under the oversight of elders because such are governed
by "the rightousness of God." For example, the church is "charged" to relieve certain widows. I Tim. 5:16.
Inasmuch as elders are commanded to "take care of the church," of necessity elders would oversee the church's
relieving these widows. Whatever is involved in the relief of widows indeed falls under the category of taking
care of the church. It is as unscriptural for elders to delegate this phase of "taking care of the church of God"
to a benevolent institution as it would be for thern to delegate such taking care of to a missionary institution
in the matter of evangelization.


A NEW TEACHING REGARDING THE OVERSIGHT OF ELDERS AND BENEVOLENCE HAS
ARISEN INTHE LAST GENERATION AMONG CHRISTIANS. THIS NEW TEACHING IS THAT
ELDERS CANNOT OVERSEE THE BENEVOLENT RESPONSIBILITIES WHICH ARE CHARGED TO
THE CHURCH. This teaching flies in the face of the plain revelation of God's word that elders are charged
with overseeing whatever the church is authorized to do. If this teaching gains a great deal of hold it will make
the church only a subsidiary to human institutions. It might also be well to note at this juncture that the church's
benevolent charge is much narrower and more restricted than many have imagined.


(3) SCOPE OF THEIR OVERSIGHT. Paul and Silas "ordained elders in every church." Acts 14:23.
Elders are to tend only the flock which is among them. I Pet. 5:2. THE SCOPE OF THEIR OVERSIGHT IS
PRESCRIBED AND THAT WHICH DOES NOT FALL WITHIN THIS SCOPE IS PROSCRIBED. THE
NATURE OF THEIR WORK PRECLUDES THE POSSIBILITY OF BEING ABLE TO OVERSEE MORE
THAN ONE CHURCH. EACH CHURCH OF CHRIST IS INDEPENDENT FROM EVERY OTHER
CHURCH OF CHRIST ON EARTH. CHRISTIANS ARE IN FELLOWSHIP WITH EVERY OTHER
CHRISTIAN BUT THE FELLOWSHIP OF CHURCHES IS A THING UNKNOWN IN THE New
Testament. The beginning of pyramidal authority was and is elders serving over more than one church. Man
cannot improve on God's plan.


In view of the Scriptures on this point, it is absolutely inconceivable that one brother who has recently
produced a book designed "to ease tensions" could conclude, "Elders of one church are authorized to make
decisions on behalf of other churches even without their permission." The gap of apostacy is widening. In
another place, this brother speaks OF ELDERS DELEGATING authority to other churches. He fails to
understand that elders only oversee and direct those in the local church. It is unscriptural to voluntarily delegate
oversight to another congregation.


The only fellowship over which elders may rule is the working together of Christians in a local church. It
is unscriptural for them to rule over the working together of churches. The local church must be sure that the
tasks it performs fall within that which God has assigned.


Truth Magazine IV:1, pp. 4-5
October 1959

Share