Rebuttal to – “The Yo-Yo Syndrome”

By Robert Walters

This article is a response to an article by Larry Hafley that appeared in the June 7th issue of Guardian of Truth. The article was entitled, “The Yo-Yo Syndrome.” This brother had some things to say about an article that appeared in Vanguard (March ’84). First, I want it to be understood that I do not believe that, “I have eternal life right now,” as was quoted from Barney Cargile. We can have confidence that we are in a saved condition and can have “hope” of eternal life, but we do not yet have it in “fact.” Aside from this one point, the article in Vanguard has some things to say worthy of our serious consideration.

I believe that there are two extreme positions on this security issue. One is that a child of God cannot commit sin unto death (fall from grace). The other is the idea that every sin is unto death (spiritual separation from God). I believe the truth is between these extreme views, and I see no reason to be afraid of teaching what the Bible clearly teaches.

The place to begin in studying this subject is 1 John 1:7. “But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin”. I verily believe that a child of God can “walk in the light” even though he has not reached the point of perfection. I stress the word walk as opposed to Yo-Yo. I believe that children of God can and do fall, but I believe that the “Yo-Yo Syndrome” doctrine is opposed to the biblical phrase “walk in the light.” It upholds the idea that every time a Christian sins (misses the mark), he goes down, and then at the very instant he confesses it, the “Yo-Yo” is back in the hand again.

Before you can accept what I’m trying to set forth, you must be able to see that God considers some sins to be greater than others. This deduction is obvious when we consider the consequences of various examples of transgressions given in the Old Testament. Perhaps many have already come to your mind if you are a veteran Bible student. One such example is found in Numbers 15:27-30. “And if any should sin through ignorance, then he shall bring a she goat of the first year for a sin offering . . . But the soul that doeth ought presumptuously . . . shall be cut off from among his people.” This passage leaves no doubt that a “presumptuous” sin is greater, in the eyes of God, than a “sin of ignorance. ” The only point that I’m making here is that God recognizes a difference in sins. You can see that He does.

John says,”. . there is sin not leading to death” (1 Jn.5:17, NKJB). This is sin that does not result in spiritual death. The “Yo-Yo syndrome” doctrine is the idea that, every time a Christian sins, he dies or that it is “unto death.” This is opposed to what John said and it is not taught in the Bible. The Bible teaches that “sin” causes death but some “Church of Christ preachers” add the word “every.” It reminds me of what the Baptists do to the word “faith.”

If brother Hafley had upheld the Bible doctrine that a child of God can “walk in the light” and be cleansed of all sin by the blood of Christ, his Baptist friend, who he debated, would likely not have called him a “Yo-Yo.” Furthermore, he might have avoided the humiliation of being called a “Yo-Yo” and, who knows, he might even have been able to teach him. But they can’t and won’t believe the “Yo-Yo” doctrine. Why ask them to? Brethren talk about the consequences of my position. The argument goes both ways.

Brethren, Let’s leave the Yo-Yo’s to the kids and do our best to walk (not Yo-Yo) in the light.

Guardian of Truth XXVIII: 17, p. 518
September 6, 1984

“How Shall The Young Secure Their Hearts?”: CHOOSING OUR RECREATION

By Titus Edwards

“All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy!” We all recognize the need for recreation and entertainment. We need the diversion from our normal routines; the refreshment and relaxation that recreation provides. And to be honest about it, we all enjoy recreation and entertainment! With a good standard of living prevalent and much free time to spend, more and more time is being spent on leisurely activities.

What do we do for entertainment? Most young people decide that question on the basis of whatever they enjoy doing. If it is sports, or bowling, or going to a movie, then so be it. If it ig going to wild parties, dancing, drinking, or speeding around town showing off, then so be it. Let me suggest that much of the recreation of young people is ungodly. We, as God’s children, hopefully concerned about right and wrong, need to be a little more discriminating in the kinds of leisurely activities that we engage in. The philosophy of, “eat, drink and be merry, for tomorrow we get older and can’t have any more fun” certainly misleads us into worldly amusements.

How can we decide what forms of recreation and entertainment we should and should not do? Easy! Just let the Bible be your guide! If you think that sounds a little simplistic, then I agree with you! It is not that easy! Indeed the Bible must be our guide in this matter (2 Tim.3:16-17), but the answers are not always so clear cut and easy. Oh, there are some things that the Bible specifically condemns, like unmarried sex, drinking, using drugs, etc. (Gal.5:19-21). But most of you would recognize that these things are wrong. If you do them, it is in willful violation of God’s word, and you knew that at the time.

But let us remember that the Bible is a book of principles. Everything is not spelled out in “thou shalt nots. ” Specifics of sin may change with different cultures, but principles can always apply. The key is getting your heart right! Be truly concerned about righteousness and serving God. If you do, then you can take the principles of the Scriptures and have little trouble in determining what you should and should not do. Here are some guidelines to help you.

Is it a form of evil? (1 Thess.5:22)

Is it illegal? (Rom.13:1-7)

Is it physically harmful? (1 Cor.6:19-20)

Will it hurt my Influence? (Rom.14:21; 1 Tim.4:12)

Does it gain control of me? (1 Cor.6:12)

Will it create lust? (James 1:14; 1 Jn.2:16)

Will it violate my conscience? (Rom.14:23)

Will it associate me with evil? (Eph.5:11)

Young people, don’t play with fire! Much recreation is really “wreck-reation” for it wrecks and ruins the lives of those who involve themselves in it. Learn these principles. Seek to apply them. The key is in recognizing that Christianity effects every phase of your life, right down to what you do for recreation and entertainment. Be concerned enough about going to heaven to let the principles of God guide you, not just “whatever feels good, do it!”

Guardian of Truth XXVIII: 17, p. 520
September 6, 1984

Have Ye Not Read?

By Hoyt Houchen

Question: Would you please explain Mark 9:38-40 and Luke 9:49,50? Christ said “not to hinder” yet many denominations do and claim many things in the name of Christ.

Reply: The account in Mark 9:38-40 is as follows: “John said unto him, Teacher, we saw one casting out demons in thy name; and we forbade him, because he followed not us. But Jesus said, Forbid him not: for there is no man who shall do a mighty work in my name, and be able to speak evil of me.” The incident as recorded by Mark is developed a little more fully than that of Luke; but they are parallel accounts, so the wording is about the same.

Neither this passage nor any other Bible passage justifies denominationalism. In our text, we see a man who was casting out demons in the name of Christ. John and the other disciples had forbidden him because he was not following with them, but was independent of the group. However, Jesus said, “Forbid him not: for he that is not against you is for you” (Lk.9:50).

The explanation of this passage is found in the expression “in thy name.” This man was casting out demons in the name of Jesus. He was doing what Jesus authorized; thus, this was not the reason that John and the other disciples forbade the man. They did not forbid him because he was casting out demons in the name of Christ, but because “he followeth not with us.” This was their reason. Simply because this man was working apart from the disciples did not make his work unauthorized. His work was sanctioned, even though he was unknown to John and the other disciples. This is why Jesus encouraged the man’s work. Brethren today may be separated by thousands of miles and may be unknown to one another; but if they are all doing the Lord’s work, the Lord endorses them. It is refreshing to meet brethren in distant fields who are doing what the New Testament authorizes them to do.

“In the name of the Lord” means by the Lord’s authority but we should carefully note that all who claim to be doing their work in the name of the Lord are not doing so. The Scriptures alone must determine this. Those who sprinkle and pour water, claiming it to be baptism, or who use mechanical instruments in worship, are not doing these things in the name of the Lord even though they claim to be. The man whom John was forbidding was not in that category; he was working in harmony with the Lord’s will. Anyone should be encouraged to do this.

It is only right and proper to forbid a person to act if his action is wrong. For instance, the mouths of false teachers should be stopped (Tit. 1:10, 11). But on the other hand, if we find those who are acting in accord with the teaching of God’s word, they should be encouraged. We are not to forbid people’s actions only upon the basis that they are unknown to us and not in our own particular circle of activity. This is the mistake John and the other disciples made – “he followeth not with us.” Although denominationalism may teach and practice some things which are scriptural, it promotes division and its very existence is the antithesis of the unity for which Jesus prayed (Jn.17:20,21) and for which Paul wrote (1 Cor. 1:10). Denominationalism does not exist “in the name of Christ,” and therefore it is without divine sanction.

Guardian of Truth XXVIII: 17, p. 522
September 6, 1984

Shall We Continue In Sin?

By Raymond E. Harris

In Romans 6: 1, the Apostle Paul sets forth the foregoing question and then answers with a thunder, “God Forbid!” At this time, we will lift the question from its technical setting and stress some simple but challenging questions.

1. Shall We Continue In Sin When We Know Its Origin? In 1 John 3:4, we learn that, “Sin is the transgression of the law.” And, in 1 John 3:8, we are further informed that “the devil sinneth from the beginning.” Further, everyone who has read, so much as the first three chapters of the first book of the Bible will remember that it was the serpent (Satan) who enticed Eve to commit the first sin.

Yes, in Genesis 3:1-6, the serpent lied by assuring Eve she would not die if she disobeyed God. Further, the serpent implied that God had selfish reasons for insisting that Adam and Eve abstain from the one forbidden tree. In John 8:44, Jesus said, “Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth because there is no truth in him.”

Hence, those who engage in rebellious acts against the will of God are said to be servants (slaves of both Satan and sin). Such are described as Satan’s children in Satan’s family, rebellious wicked citizens of Satan’s kingdom.

It would seem that if our knowledge of sin was limited only to the foregoing – we would flee from all unrighteousness. Who among us would want to be in the kingdom of Hitler or the child of a Charles Manson. Much more, how awful to be the slave child of the devil! Knowing the origin of sin, shall we continue in sin! God Forbid!

2. Shall We Continue In Sin When We Know Its History! Some histories are interesting and worthwhile, but the history of sin is dark and dreadful. As every Bible student knows, the black history of sin begins in Genesis 3:6. On that occasion, first Eve and then Adam disregarded the reasonable limitations of God, questioned His integrity, and willfully disobeyed Him.

The consequences of their iniquity were immediately forthcoming! They began to die physically. But, even worse, they died spiritually! The word “death,” means “separation.” Hence, we see that physical death is the separation of the body and the spirit. And spiritual death is the separation of the eternal soul from God!

It seems that once sin (rebellion) was loose in the world it has rolled like a tidal wave over generation after generation. In Genesis 3, Eve and Adam sinned. In Genesis 4, Cain became the world’s first murderer. And by Genesis 6, ten generations have come upon the earth. At that point God noted that “the wickedness of man was great in the earth” (Gen. 6:5). Hence, through the grace of God and the righteousness of Noah and his family, human life on earth was allowed to continue. All others died because of their iniquity.

But, as we continue to Genesis 12, we learn that after another ten generations mankind was rebellious and as wicked as before the flood. Hence, at that point, God called Abram to separate himself and form a special people from whom Jesus, the Savior could come.

As we turn on through our Bibles we learn that sin:

a. Caused the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah.

b. Caused the downfall and death of King Saul.

c. Caused shame and a life time of woe to King David.

d. Caused both Israel and Judah to spend 70 years in slavery.

e. Caused the crucifixion of Jesus.

f. Causes the damnation of all who will not turn to Christ and obey the gospel.

Also, when we consider the history of sin, we find that the page of our life is also there! Sin has and will continue to create misery, sorrow and despair in our lives so long as we live.

Truly, when we consider the history of sin, we should determine that we will not continue therein. God forbid!

3. Shall We Continue In Sin When We Know Its Trend? There is no question, the trend of sin has always been and always shall be downward. No one ever became a better person by flaunting and rebelling against the laws of God.

In 2 Timothy 3:13, Paul wrote, “But evil men and seducers shall wax worse and worse . . . .” And so, sin is invariably a progressive influence. Sin sears the conscience and the last sin eases the way for the next.

A classic example of the progressiveness of sin is seen in the lives of Joseph’s older brethren as revealed in Genesis 37. As the story unfolds, we learn that Jacob loved his son Joseph more than any of his ten older sons. From this volatile environment came forth a growing and progressive evil attitude on the part of these ten young men. The Bible tells us that their emotions and actions evolved from hate, to envy, to selling their own brother as a slave and finally to the cunning deception of their father. Hence, we see the initial sins of jealousy, hate and envy, open the doors to such violent sins as assault and kidnaping.

Invariably one sin will lead to another and the second is usually worse than the first. So, unless we “come to” ourselves and wake up to what sin is doing to us, there will come total destruction of both body and soul. Truly, we cannot take fire unto our bosom and not be burned! Sin separates from God, it damns the soul, and it will not be allowed in heaven.

Shall we continue in sin? God forbid!

4. Shall We Continue In Sin When We Know Its Results? The results of sin have been so varied and devastating it is impossible to really comprehend the vastness of sin and the immeasurableness of the suffering it has caused.

Sin has destroyed reputations, good names, family trust, marital happiness and self-respect. A night’s unrestricted indulgence in sin has produced separation, divorce and murder. A night’s unrestricted indulgence in sin has produced illegitimate children, introduction into crime, incurable disease, disgrace, imprisonment and premature death.

Also, sin has destroyed minds and emotions as well as physical bodies. Sanitariums and asylums abound with both perpetrators and victims of sin. Mental breakdowns and suicide are common results of ungodliness.

And then, the ultimate result of sin is the everlasting loss of the soul. Physical and mental suffering are devastating. However, loss of the soul is even worse. Jesus explained that the wicked would be cast into “outer darkness” where there will be “weeping and gnashing of teeth.” He later said those cursed by sin, would depart “into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels. ” And in John 5:28-29, the Lord explained that on judgment day, “all that are in the graves shall hear his voice, and shall come forth.” And He further explains that those that have lived evil lives will come forth, “unto the resurrection of damnation.”

My friend, when we consider the results of sin, even in our own lives, we should be shocked into repentance. Who among us has not suffered greatly physically and mentally because of sin. And what about our souls? When we consider that life is short and judgment is sure, shall we continue in sin? God forbid!

5. Shall We Continue In Sin When We Know Its Remedy? In Romans 6:23, Paul warns that “the wages of sin is death . . .” And in Galatians 5:19-21, he enumerates the “works of the flesh.” He declares that those who continue in such wretched ways “shall not inherit the kingdom of God.”

And when Paul, wrote to the Philippians he helps us to understand that good worthwhile thoughts help prevent sin. He explains that we should dwell on things that are true, honest, just, pure, lovely, and of a good report. However, these good thoughts will not remedy or remove the sins we have already committed.

Yet, we must realize that with the sacrifice of Jesus and the preaching of the gospel, remission of sins is now possible. Yes, forgiveness of sins is now available to all. You remember Jesus said, “Come unto me, all ye that labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matt. 11:28).

But, what is the remedy for sin?

a. Belief in God (Heb. 11:6); in Jesus (John 3:16); in the gospel (Rom. 1:16, Mk. 16:16b).

b. Repentance or turning from sin (Lk. 13:3; Acts 17:30; Acts 2:38).

c. Confession that Jesus is the Son of God (Matt. 10:32; Acts 8:36-37; Rom. 10:10).

d. Baptism (immersion) in water (Mk. 16:16; Acts 2:38; 8:38-39; 18:8; 22:16; Rom. 6:3-5).

So, we see that the grace of God has provided a way of escape! Yes, by accepting Jesus as our Savior and obeying the terms or conditions that God has laid down, anyone can have remission of his sins. This obedience and remission of sins by God, allows each one to be a Christian, a member of Christ’s Church, and a citizen of God’s Kingdom!

Considering that there is a remedy for sins, shall we continue in sin? God forbid!

Guardian of Truth XXVIII: 16, pp. 492-493
August 16, 1984